1937-D Three Legged Buffalo Nickel PCGS/CAC MS65

Your Price:
$39,500.00 You save: $5,750.00 (14.56%) $33,750.00


Ships Free!

Markets Change Rapidly. Contact Us For Current Inventory and Prices.

We ship fast! All orders leave our warehouse within one business day.

4 Great Reasons To Buy From Us:

  • Image of Image of Image of
  • Image of Image of Image of
  • Image of Image of Image of
  • Image of Image of Image of

The 1937-D Three-Legged variety is the result of a heavily eroded tail die being vigorously lapped in an effort to smooth out the fields for continued coinage. Effacing the bison's forward right leg was an accidental consequence that may have gone completely unnoticed by mint employees. But coins struck after the fact have become one of the most sought-after varieties of the entire Buffalo nickel series.

Available for a price through MS64, the Three-Legged variety becomes genuinely scarce in Gem condition, and anything finer is a great rarity that most collectors can only dream of owning.

PCGS population of just 54 with 18 higher (8 of which are MS65+).

Listed at:

  • $35,200 in Numismedia (CAC)

  • $39,500 in (PCGS+) in PCGS price guide.

Indian Head (Buffalo) 5 Cents

Paul Gilkes - 

"Buffalo nickel" most American coin By Paul Gilkes
COIN WORLD Staff Renowned sculptor James Earle Fraser was fascinated by the American Indian, so much so that it was no surprise he chose an Indian motif for the 5-cent coin design. And the bison design for the reverse made a perfect companion image.

It is arguably the most "American" of all United States coins and is a collector favorite.

Fraser's artistic prowess earned the undying respect of a dying Augustus Saint-Gaudens, who recommended Fraser to President Theodore Roosevelt to sculpture the official presidential bust. Roosevelt and Fraser became quick friends.

Despite the fact that William Howard Taft was president in 1912, it was Roosevelt who recommended that Fraser be chosen to design the copper-nickel 5-cent coin, overdue by five years for a design change. In the early 20th century, coin designs were usually changed every 25 years automatically.

The obverse design for the Indian Head 5-cent coin, commonly called the "Buffalo nickel," depicts a large, powerful portrait of an Indian, facing right. The appearance is rough-hewn, unlike the smooth cheeks and other facial features that characterize innumerable Liberty renditions. The portrait is purported to be a composite of three Indians, although the identities of the models have been disputed. A few Native Americans laid claim to be the model for the coin. Frazer identified the models as Iron Tail, a Sioux; Big Tree, a Kiowa; and Two Moons, a Cheyenne. All three visited Roosevelt while in New York City, according to Fraser, who studied and photographed them during their stay.

Fraser's designer initial, F, appears incuse below the date on the obverse. More is known about the American bison that served as the model for the reverse design. It was Black Diamond, an inhabitant of the New York Zoological Park. Fraser employed a little artistic license to portray the bison as though he were living free on the Great Plains. The stuffed head of Black Diamond was displayed at a major coin convention during the 1980s.

During the inaugural 1913 year, two distinct subtypes were produced at the Philadelphia, Denver and San Francisco Mints: the Bison on Mound and the Bison on Plain. Because of the fear that the FIVE CENTS denomination legend on the reverse would wear off quickly in circulation, Chief Engraver Charles E. Barber modified the reverse hub.

Barber placed FIVE CENTS within an exergue to protect it from excessive wear, reducing the mound to level ground. Barber also smoothed down the roughened fields that gave the coin its distinctive look.

Among the challenging dates to find are the 1916 Doubled Die, of which approximately 100 pieces in all grades are believed to exist.

The 1918/7-D coin was created during a die shortage when a 1917 working die was impressed with that of a hub dated 1918.

The 1937-D Three-Legged Bison coin resulted from a Mint technician overpolishing a reverse die, taking away a portion of one of the two forelegs.

The Indian Head 5-cent coin is a popular series with collectors. High-quality collections offered for sale at coin shows are quickly gobbled up to meet market demand.

After its legislated 25-year run, the Indian Head 5-cent coin was replaced in 1938 by a new design depicting the third president of the United States, Thomas Jefferson.

Indian Head 5 cents

Date of authorization: May 16, 1866

Dates of issue: 1913-1938

Designer: James Earle Fraser

Engraver: Charles Barber

Diameter: 21.21 mm/0.84 inch

Weight: 5.00 grams/0.16 ounce

Metallic content: 75% copper, 25% nickel

Edge: Plain

Mint mark: Reverse below FIVE CENTS


All items are shipped within 3 – 5 business days after receipt of payment unless otherwise stated at the time of purchase. Sets may require an additional 2 – 3 days for assembly and completion.We ship via US Postal Service: First Class Mail, Priority Mail and Express Mail services are available.

With the exception of Bullion Items, Eastern Numismatics offers a 30-day unconditional return guarantee covering our Numismatic and Collectible Items. Returned items must be received at ENI within 30-days of their delivery to the client for this guarantee to be in effect. Items must be sent to: ENI, 642 Franklin Avenue, Garden City NY 11530 Attn: Returns.

Let our four decades of honest service and industry networks work for you. Our efforts to improve product quality and service has led us to a diverse and exeptional numismatic inventory in order to meet the challenges of today’s rare coin market and the needs of our clients. We have been servicing investors and collectors since 1974 and are members of all major consumer and trade organizations, including the American Numismatic Association, the Better Business Bureau, the Professional Numismatists Guild. At Eastern Numismatics we are ready to work for you and help turn your rare coin investment into gold. Call today and speak with one of our qualified ENI coin consultants. They will help you select the best quality rare coins and precious metals for your hard earned money.

Related Products

1921 Morgan Silver Dollar Rolls - Mint State - BU Condition $999 While Supplies Last!
Engelhard & Johnson Matthey- 100oz Silver Bars- All Silver is CME & London Approved (Spot + $6.75)- Call for the "Lowest Price" Anywhere! ****Available for Immediate delivery****
PAMP 1 Ounce Gold Bar - Call for Lowest Price "Anywhere" $2028